Full case report

Bedford v The Number (UK) Ltd

Reference [2004] ISLR SLR-18
Court OFCOM

Judge Content Board

Date of Judgment 27 Jan 2004


Summary

Intellectual property- sports law- OFCOM- Advertising- complaint under r 6.5 ITC Advertising Code – whether the claimant was caricatured in a 118 advert


Facts

David Bedford broke the 10,000 metres world record in 1973. He had a particular hairstyle with a “zapata” moustache and ran in distinctive sky-blue shorts and red socks. He saw the 118 adverts where the runners looked similar to him. He did not object for a period of 6 months because he thought he had no legal remedy, having been so advised. The Number spent considerable sums in developing their advertisements in the meantime.


Issue

What was the appropriate test for portrayal or caricature – did the adverts portrary or caricature David Bedord – if so, what should be done by OFCOM.


Held

The adverts did caricature him. The Number did not obtain his permission. There was a breach of rule 6.5 of the Code. However, it would be disproportionate to direct that the adverts should not be carried. Finding of breach held to be a sufficient resolution of the matter.


Comment

The complaint illustrates the possibilities of obtaining a de facto personality right through the broadcasting Advertising Code.


Instructing Solicitors

Couchman Harrington