Misuse of private information – Data Protection Act 1998 – Police law – Damages
Appearances: Kate Wilson led by Paul Stagg KC (Defendant)
GDB was the headmaster and owner of a private school. In February 2017, the local authority received complaints about GDB which were treated as raising safeguarding concerns. Ofsted carried out an emergency school inspection. Following a multi-agency safeguarding meeting in March 2017, the police commenced an investigation. The police obtained warrants to search the school and other premises. The claimant was arrested on suspicion of voyeurism and possessing indecent images of children.
A journalist obtained the notice which the school had sent to parents about the emergency Ofsted inspection and the police investigation, which included that the headmaster was temporarily stepping aside but did not refer to the arrest. The journalist later contacted the defendant’s press bureau asking about an investigation at the school and referring to the headmaster have stepped aside. The press bureau gave a statement that; confirmed an investigation was ongoing in the relevant local authority; “a XX-year-old man was arrested on Tuesday 4 April on suspicion of voyeurism and possessing indecent images of children”; and had been bailed. At the same time, the press bureau told the journalist “we do not confirm names of people who may or may not be subject to a police investigation” [149].
A week later, the newspaper published an article online and in the paper. It included some information from the press lines, although not the age of the man arrested. It identified the school.
In May 2017, GDB was interviewed under caution about an allegation of (historic) sexual assault. In June, the journalist contacted the defendant’s press bureau asking for an update on the investigation. The press bureau repeated the previous press lines and (wrongly) informed him that GDB had been arrested on suspicion of sexual assault. That was included in a second article about the investigation, although the press lines and the article were corrected the following day. The second article identified that the person arrested was a member of staff.
By September 2018, GDB had found a buyer for the school and sold it.
GDB was never charged with any offence, and the police closed their investigation in November 2018.
The claimant claimed for (i) trespass in respect to the searches of the school, his home and car, (ii) false imprisonment in respect to his arrest, (iii) under the Human Rights Act for breach of his Article 8 rights in respect to the searches, (iv) misuse of private information in respect to the press lines given to the journalist and (iv) breach of the Data Protection Act 1998 in respect to the inaccurate information (in the second press line) that he had been arrested.
He claimed substantial special damages for loss of income and capital loss. He claimed that the decline in pupil numbers in 2017/2018 was attributable to the media’s reporting of the police’s press lines and that he sold the school for less than it would otherwise have been worth as a result.
At the trial, all issues of liability and quantum were in dispute. Of most interest to media lawyers are the issues of:
Mr Justice Jay considered that the case generally raised “complex issues of liability and causation”.
Save for the claim under the Human Rights Act, which was time-barred and in respect to which Jay J refused to extend time, and an element of the trespass claim, the claimant succeeded on all causes of action. While the judge found that the police had obtained warrants for all premises which were searched (copies were no longer available given the passage of time), he was critical of the way in which the investigation had been conducted.
The misuse of private information claim largely turned on whether the press bureau had identified GDB such as to bring his claim within the scope of the principles in ZXC v Bloomberg LP [2022] AC 1158 – those principles being common ground.
It was held that the defendant’s ‘NCND’ (neither confirm nor deny) statement to the journalist did not “neutralise the identifying information” supplied by the press bureau [217]. The journalist had asked about an investigation at the school where the headmaster had stepped aside, and in those circumstances the information supplied, while not naming GDB or referring to the school or a teacher, identified him/ was likely to do so [185-194] and was, therefore, a misuse of his private information.
It was further held that the defendant was liable in damages for the repetition of that private information in the two newspaper articles. In so holding, the judge rejected the defendant’s case, including that the publication of other information in those articles meant that the Commissioner should not be held responsible for any such damage because that other information and the editorial judgement exercised by the publisher broke the chain of causation. Because the claimant has anonymity, the judgment does not include the articles.
Jay J awarded the claimant £80,000 damages for the two misuse of private information claims, which included a modest award for the data protection claim.
In doing so, he held that damages for reputational harm are recoverable in a misuse of private information claim: “I would formulate the principle in this way. Damages are recoverable for the impact upon the claimant’s personal and private life caused by reputational harm flowing from the misuse of this private information. That the Claimant was under police investigation and had been arrested was factually true, but the policy of the law, confirmed by ZXC3, is that he had a reasonable expectation of privacy in relation to those (true) facts.” [255].
Jay J continued: “There is, in any event, a significant degree of overlap in a case such as this between damages for distress and damages for reputational harm. The Claimant’s evidence is that the publications in the newspaper were “disastrous” and “intrusive”, and left him “feeling like damaged goods”. The stigma was obvious. The claim for reputational damage in this particular case does not add much to the claims which are uncontroversial.”
The judge’s decision on the principle of recoverability of damages for reputational harm does not, it appear, import defamation principles governing the assessment of damages for libel into claims for misuse of private information. He made no reference to them, and proceeded on the basis that the information was true [253]. However, having regard to his rejection of the analysis of Warby J (as he then was) in Sicri v Associated Newspapers Ltd [2021] 4 WLR 9, and his reasoning that there was significant overlap with the heads of damages which were not in dispute, an indication of the extent to which he increased the award to take account of “reputational harm” would have been useful to understand what difference it made to damages under established heads.
The decision is also of interest in terms of the approach which the judge took to causation in the special damages claim where there were a number of different causes, including non-tortious ones, of the loss of income and the capital loss, where the immediate cause of the drop of pupil numbers was the decision of third parties (i.e. parents). The judge applied a loss of a chance approach: [269] [301-305].